|

|  Error: You cannot define a static route with the same name as a dynamic route in Next.js: Causes and How to Fix

Error: You cannot define a static route with the same name as a dynamic route in Next.js: Causes and How to Fix

February 10, 2025

Discover why a static route can't share a name with a dynamic route in Next.js. Learn common causes and step-by-step solutions to resolve this error.

What is Error: You cannot define a static route with the same name as a dynamic route in Next.js

 

Understanding the Error

 

  • In Next.js, routing is a core aspect of the application structure, allowing developers to manage navigation and page rendering efficiently. This error arises when there is a naming conflict between static and dynamic routes in the Next.js routing system.
  •  

  • A static route is defined by creating a new file in the `pages` directory without any brackets, e.g., `about.js` for `/about` path.
  •  

  • A dynamic route allows for variable segments in the URL, created using square brackets, such as `[id].js`, and can be accessed at paths like `/post/1` or `/post/2`.
  •  

  • The error typically occurs when there is an attempt to define both a static and dynamic route with the same segment name. Next.js routing prevents two routes from occupying the same URL path to avoid ambiguity in route resolution.

 

Conceptual Explanation with Example

 

  • Consider a Next.js application where you have a static route, `pages/profile.js`, intended to serve a user's profile page at `/profile`.
  •  

  • If you also create a dynamic route `pages/[profile].js`, designed to manage different profiles at the URL `/profile/john`, the static and dynamic routes will conflict if accessed at `/profile` due to both competing to serve this path.

 

// File: pages/profile.js
export default function Profile() {
  return <h1>Static Profile Page</h1>;
}

// File: pages/[profile].js
import { useRouter } from 'next/router';

export default function UserProfile() {
  const { query } = useRouter();
  return <h1>Dynamic Profile for {query.profile}</h1>;
}

 

Implications of the Error

 

  • This error highlights the importance of clear naming conventions and route structures in Next.js applications. When crafting routes, it is vital to ensure that static and dynamic segments do not overlap unintentionally.
  •  

  • Static routes are prioritized over dynamic routes during the routing resolution process. It means if a conflict arises, the static route will take precedence, potentially leading to dynamic routes not being rendered as expected.
  •  

  • Naming conventions help maintain clarity, improve navigation, and avoid conflicts. Proper management of static and dynamic routes prevents rendering issues and enhances the overall development experience.

 

What Causes Error: You cannot define a static route with the same name as a dynamic route in Next.js

 

Understanding the Error: Static vs. Dynamic Routes in Next.js

 

  • In Next.js, routing is based on the file system, which means each file in the `pages` directory automatically becomes a route available to the application.
  •  

  • Static routes are defined by the file name itself, for example, a file named `about.js` under the `pages` directory corresponds to the `/about` route in the application.
  •  

  • Dynamic routes, on the other hand, are determined at runtime and typically utilize brackets in their filename to indicate dynamic segments, like `[id].js` for dynamic route matching.
  •  

  • The error occurs when there is an attempted overlap in naming between static and dynamic routes, where a static file path directly conflicts with a dynamic segment definition.

 

Duplicate Route Paths

 

  • A common cause is having both a static page and a dynamic page that generate the same route. For example, having `pages/blog/index.js` and `pages/blog/[slug].js` can potentially lead to conflicts if the dynamic route does not effectively exclude the static page's path.

 

Naming Conflicts

 

  • Naming conflicts occur when developers name their files without considering these overlaps. For instance, both `pages/user.js` and `pages/[user].js` intended as separate concerns may inadvertently conflict if accessed in a manner not explicit in the design.

 

Path Matching Conflicts

 

  • Dynamic routes are often prioritized over static ones when both exist in the same path namespace, potentially causing errors if an expected static route is overridden by the dynamic logic.
  •  

  • The file system-based routing mechanism has a clear resolution path where specific paths are matched first, potentially leading to unexpected behavior when there is overlap.

 

Example of Conflicting Routes

 

Assume the following structure in the pages directory:

 

/pages
  /product
    index.js
    [id].js

 

  • If a developer tries to access `/product` as both a static path from `index.js` and a dynamic path from `[id].js`, there will be a conflict due to overlapping route definitions.
  •  

  • In this case, accessing a URL like `/product/42` may result in unexpected behavior if not properly handled, as the system might attempt various resolutions that aren't intended.

 

Design Misunderstandings

 

  • Some misunderstandings stem from a lack of awareness of how Next.js prioritizes routes. Dynamic routes might unexpectedly shadow static routes when developers lack clarity about the significance of naming and file placement.
  •  

  • This misunderstanding often leads to developers inadvertently setting up routes that manifest this error due to the file structure rather than any explicit coding mistake.

 

Omi Necklace

The #1 Open Source AI necklace: Experiment with how you capture and manage conversations.

Build and test with your own Omi Dev Kit 2.

How to Fix Error: You cannot define a static route with the same name as a dynamic route in Next.js

 

Resolve Naming Conflicts

 

  • Ensure that your static and dynamic routes have unique names. Check the dynamic route defined in your pages directory and ensure there isn't a corresponding static route with the same name.
  •  

  • In Next.js, a dynamic route is often defined with square brackets, for example, pages/user/[id].js. A conflicting static route might be pages/user/id.js.

 

Refactor Folder Structure

 

  • If possible, refactor your project structure to maintain clear differentiation between static and dynamic routes. For instance, move dynamic routes to a nested directory that better signifies their purpose.
  •  

  • For example, consider changing pages/user/[id].js to pages/user/dynamic/[id].js to avoid conflict and maintain clarity.

 

Leverage getStaticPaths and getStaticProps

 

  • For static pages within a dynamic routing context, use getStaticProps where it helps in building pages with static content.
  •  

  • Implement getStaticPaths in your dynamic route files to define the paths that should be statically generated during the build process.

 


// pages/user/[id].js

export async function getStaticPaths() {
  // Return a list of possible `id` values
  const paths = [
    { params: { id: '1' } },
    { params: { id: '2' } },
  ];

  return { paths, fallback: false };
}

export async function getStaticProps({ params }) {
  // Fetch necessary data for the blog post using params.id
  const userData = fetchDataById(params.id);
  
  return {
    props: {
      userData,
    },
  };
}

 

Check for Next.js Version Issues

 

  • Ensure your Next.js version supports the features you are using, as conflicts sometimes emerge from deprecated or outdated practices.
  •  

  • Upgrade if necessary by running:

 


npm install next@latest

 

Deploy Separately Named Routes

 

  • Avoid similar parameter names in dynamic routes and their corresponding static paths. For example, instead of having both pages/article/[slug].js and a static pages/article/slug.js, consider renaming the static path.
  •  

  • A practical approach might involve designating non-conflicting path segments for static content, such as renaming to pages/article/staticSlugPage.js.

 


// Example of refactored directory for static page
/pages/user/staticPage.js

// Example of refactored directory for dynamic route
/pages/user/[id].js

 

Adopt Consistent Naming Conventions

 

  • Institute consistent naming conventions throughout your project to minimize the risk of naming conflicts. Prefix static pages or include page descriptors in file names.
  •  

  • For example, prefix static page file names with a descriptive identifier like static_ or default_ to make their purpose immediately clear.

 

Omi App

Fully Open-Source AI wearable app: build and use reminders, meeting summaries, task suggestions and more. All in one simple app.

Github →

Order Friend Dev Kit

Open-source AI wearable
Build using the power of recall

Order Now

Join the #1 open-source AI wearable community

Build faster and better with 3900+ community members on Omi Discord

Participate in hackathons to expand the Omi platform and win prizes

Participate in hackathons to expand the Omi platform and win prizes

Get cash bounties, free Omi devices and priority access by taking part in community activities

Join our Discord → 

OMI NECKLACE + OMI APP
First & only open-source AI wearable platform

a person looks into the phone with an app for AI Necklace, looking at notes Friend AI Wearable recorded a person looks into the phone with an app for AI Necklace, looking at notes Friend AI Wearable recorded
a person looks into the phone with an app for AI Necklace, looking at notes Friend AI Wearable recorded a person looks into the phone with an app for AI Necklace, looking at notes Friend AI Wearable recorded
online meeting with AI Wearable, showcasing how it works and helps online meeting with AI Wearable, showcasing how it works and helps
online meeting with AI Wearable, showcasing how it works and helps online meeting with AI Wearable, showcasing how it works and helps
App for Friend AI Necklace, showing notes and topics AI Necklace recorded App for Friend AI Necklace, showing notes and topics AI Necklace recorded
App for Friend AI Necklace, showing notes and topics AI Necklace recorded App for Friend AI Necklace, showing notes and topics AI Necklace recorded

OMI NECKLACE: DEV KIT
Order your Omi Dev Kit 2 now and create your use cases

Omi 開発キット 2

無限のカスタマイズ

OMI 開発キット 2

$69.99

Omi AIネックレスで会話を音声化、文字起こし、要約。アクションリストやパーソナライズされたフィードバックを提供し、あなたの第二の脳となって考えや感情を語り合います。iOSとAndroidでご利用いただけます。

  • リアルタイムの会話の書き起こしと処理。
  • 行動項目、要約、思い出
  • Omi ペルソナと会話を活用できる何千ものコミュニティ アプリ

もっと詳しく知る

Omi Dev Kit 2: 新しいレベルのビルド

主な仕様

OMI 開発キット

OMI 開発キット 2

マイクロフォン

はい

はい

バッテリー

4日間(250mAH)

2日間(250mAH)

オンボードメモリ(携帯電話なしで動作)

いいえ

はい

スピーカー

いいえ

はい

プログラム可能なボタン

いいえ

はい

配送予定日

-

1週間

人々が言うこと

「記憶を助ける、

コミュニケーション

ビジネス/人生のパートナーと、

アイデアを捉え、解決する

聴覚チャレンジ」

ネイサン・サッズ

「このデバイスがあればいいのに

去年の夏

記録する

「会話」

クリスY.

「ADHDを治して

私を助けてくれた

整頓された。"

デビッド・ナイ

OMIネックレス:開発キット
脳を次のレベルへ

最新ニュース
フォローして最新情報をいち早く入手しましょう

最新ニュース
フォローして最新情報をいち早く入手しましょう

thought to action.

Based Hardware Inc.
81 Lafayette St, San Francisco, CA 94103
team@basedhardware.com / help@omi.me

Company

Careers

Invest

Privacy

Events

Manifesto

Compliance

Products

Omi

Wrist Band

Omi Apps

omi Dev Kit

omiGPT

Personas

Omi Glass

Resources

Apps

Bounties

Affiliate

Docs

GitHub

Help Center

Feedback

Enterprise

Ambassadors

Resellers

© 2025 Based Hardware. All rights reserved.